Short answer: it depends on what you sell and who buys it. Longer answer — and the one that actually helps — is below. We'll break it down by industry so you know where to spend your time if you only have time for one.
Every small business owner eventually asks the same question: "I can barely keep up with one. Do I really need both?" It's a fair question, and most advice answers it badly — usually with "post everywhere, all the time!" which is useless when you're running a shop and the day is already full.
So let's be honest about what each platform is actually good at, who's really on them, and how to decide where your limited time goes.
Facebook is where the local crowd lives — and it skews a little older, which for a lot of trades and service businesses is exactly your buyer. It's strong at:
If your customer is a homeowner, a parent, or a local who finds businesses by asking their network, Facebook is doing quiet, important work for you.
Instagram is visual-first and skews younger. It rewards businesses whose work photographs well and whose buyers shop with their eyes. It's strong at:
If your work is a photo — a detailed car, a plated dish, a finished renovation, a fresh haircut — Instagram is where that work earns its keep.
If your customer is older and local and finds you by word of mouth, lead with Facebook. If your work is visual and your buyer is younger, lead with Instagram. But "lead with" is not "only use" — keep reading.
Here's the by-industry cheat sheet we actually give people on calls:
Here's the thing nobody selling you "Instagram growth hacks" wants to admit. The real divide isn't Facebook versus Instagram. It's posting consistently versus not posting at all. A business that posts steadily to one platform crushes a business that posts to both for three weeks and then goes silent for two months.
And there's a third player most owners forget entirely: your Google Business Profile. When someone searches "[your trade] near me," that profile is what shows up — and an active one outranks a dormant one every time. For a lot of local businesses, Google is the highest-intent channel of the three, and it's the one most owners never touch.
Whichever platform you lead with, judge it by the right scoreboard. Most owners obsess over follower counts and likes — vanity numbers that feel good and pay nothing. The metrics that actually map to dollars are quieter:
Give any new effort a fair runway, too. Social isn't a vending machine — you don't put in a post and get a customer out the same day. Most local businesses start seeing momentum around the 60–90 day mark of consistent posting, not before. If you bail at three weeks because "nothing happened," you quit right before the part that works.
The reason "just post to both!" advice falls apart is simple: you have a business to run. Posting to two or three platforms consistently, week after week, is a real job — and it's nobody's favourite part of owning a shop. So it slips. Then the algorithm forgets you. Then you conclude "social doesn't work for my business," when really the posting just stopped.
The fix is to make it not depend on your willpower at 11pm on a Sunday. That's the whole idea behind how we run social: one set of content, posted to Facebook, Instagram, AND your Google Business Profile — all three, every post, for one flat price. You stop choosing between platforms and start showing up consistently on all of them without it eating your evenings.
Pick the one where your buyer actually is. Older, local, word-of-mouth customers? Facebook. Younger buyers and visual work? Instagram. But don't forget your Google Business Profile — for most local businesses it's the highest-intent channel of all, and the most neglected.
Not even close. It skews a little older, which for trades, home services, and professional services is often exactly your buyer. Local community groups and reviews on Facebook drive real word-of-mouth. It's quietly one of the best local channels there is.
Ideally yes, because they do different jobs — but only if you can do it consistently. One platform posted steadily beats three posted sporadically. The trick is making it not depend on your free time, which is why we post every piece of content to all three for one price.
Consistency matters more than volume. Twelve solid posts a month, spread across the channels your customers check, beats a burst of thirty followed by silence. The algorithm rewards showing up regularly far more than it rewards heroic one-off efforts.
We post your content to Facebook, Instagram, AND your Google Business Profile — every post, all three channels, for $149/mo. Written by Canadians. Month-to-month, cancel anytime.
See how social works →Free 15-minute call. No pitch, no pressure. We'll tell you honestly where your customers actually are and whether we can help you reach them.
Get Started Free → Just a neighbour helping a neighbour.